Vitalik emphasized in a post that Ethereum must be "amazing," but the foundation is not the center
Author: Gu Yu, ChainCatcher
After experiencing a series of negative events such as the continuous departure of core members and former core supporters criticizing the project, Ethereum founder Vitalik had to publish a lengthy response to the community today to quell public opinion and inject more confidence into the community.
In fact, all the negative doubts essentially stem from the decline in ETH's price. Compared to the strong performance of Hyperliquid, Ethereum lags behind in ecological prosperity, community belief, and main chain performance, resulting in its price dropping by more than 64% in the past year at most. In contrast, HYPE's price has repeatedly hit new highs, surpassing $64 at its peak.
As a result, the Ethereum community has directed its main criticism towards Ethereum's core contributor: the Ethereum Foundation. Many opinions suggest that the strategic formulation of the Ethereum Foundation is vague, with frequent upheavals in leadership, and not only has it not increased its holdings of ETH but has also continued to sell coins, failing to represent the interests of ETH holders.
Ryan Sean Adams, co-founder of Bankless, stated in a post on May 20 that Ethereum's future can no longer rely on the Ethereum Foundation (EF). "While EF is important, Ethereum needs new institutions to intervene and fill the gap. We need an organization that truly hopes for the success of Ethereum assets (ETH) — growth in quantity — and is willing to speak out and execute effectively. EF is not that, and it never will be."
Tempo researcher and former Ethereum Foundation researcher Dankrad Feist shares a similar view. He stated a few days ago that the Ethereum Foundation currently holds less than 0.1% of all ETH, with no funds flowing to it from Ethereum staking or transaction fees. The way to save Ethereum lies in the community creating an organization that aligns with Ethereum's economic interests and is accountable for them.
Veteran crypto journalist Laura Shin further pointed out that the original sin of Ethereum lies in the fact that every step since Dencun has not considered token economics, meaning that the Ethereum Foundation has overly focused on ideology while neglecting capital markets and price performance.
In response to these criticisms, Vitalik addressed the community's concerns in today's lengthy article with an honest and firm attitude, systematically elaborating on his deep thoughts regarding the role, strategic direction, and value positioning of the Foundation.
1. Facing the "Sense of Crisis": Ethereum Cannot Become "The Second Google"
Vitalik began by acknowledging a sense of "distress" — he often sees people saying: "Vitalik talks about Ethereum needing to be decentralized, needing privacy, needing to be a refuge technology, the words sound beautiful, but why do EF's actual actions not reflect these?"
He further admitted that there may be a "real difference" between his sense of crisis and that of others in the community — in terms of "which type of criticism I value most and which type of critic can hit my pain points the hardest."
To illustrate, he gave a meaningful analogy: Google. Vitalik believes that Google is a success story, "but one could also hold another view: they had a beautiful and idealistic start, but at some point, the corruption of mainstream corporate attitudes seeped in, and they gradually abandoned the 'don't be evil' motto."
He stated: "If you took me back to around 2008 and gave me a button that could raise Google's 'dogma' standards by one or two standard deviations, such as granting Richard Stallman a permanent veto over certain key policies, I would not hesitate to press it."
The reason is that the entire tech industry is drifting away from the early idealistic foundation of "don't be evil," "turning to chase financial interests, embracing the grand narrative of accelerating superintelligence that devours everything, being infiltrated by unscrupulous individuals, and cowardly yielding to government pressure in terms of ideological control, surveillance, and war." Therefore, "having a company do something different, positioning itself as the 'irrational person' as George Bernard Shaw said, resisting the tide of the times, is more beneficial for freedom, power balance, and the stability of society as a whole than all large companies succumbing to mainstream trends."
This discourse has actually set the tone for the future of the Ethereum Foundation: it will not become the second Google — it will not slide into mediocrity and corruption step by step after an idealistic opening.
2. EF is Not the Center, but a "Node with Clear Objectives"
In response to external criticisms regarding the Foundation's positioning, Vitalik provided a clear framework: EF is not "the center of Ethereum," but rather "a node with clear responsibilities alongside other nodes." He said that within the Ethereum ecosystem, "even within EF, there are many who wish for us to be the former. Now, we are taking action to ensure we become the latter."
The necessity of this shift lies in a harsh financial reality: EF holds only about 0.16% of all ETH, "less than many individual ETH holders," while in other blockchains, it is common for "central foundations" to hold 10% to 50% of the shares. Vitalik further pointed out that EF was originally designed to complete the limited scope of work defined in the token sale documents, which was fully completed in 2022, "it was never designed to be an eternal manager."
Therefore, Vitalik stated that EF will choose to use its remaining resources to pursue long-term goals rather than blindly expanding. EF will clearly focus on activities that are crucial for Ethereum's success as a censorship-resistant, capture-resistant, open, private, and secure system, and that would not happen without their promotion. He particularly emphasized that EF will no longer continue to sell large amounts of ETH.
3. Ethereum Must Be "Amazing"
Vitalik put forward a clear viewpoint in the lengthy article: Ethereum must be "amazing."
"We live in an era of highly intelligent AI and various technological accelerations. 'Maintaining the status quo of EVM, hard forking once or twice a year to meet users' short-term needs' is unimaginative."
But for some, "amazing" means 250 milliseconds of latency and 1 million TPS. Vitalik bluntly stated: "I think it would be a mistake for Ethereum to go down this path. Pursuing speed and scalability while being only slightly better in decentralization is a path to mediocrity, and if we do this, we will inevitably fail."
He believes Ethereum should strive in another dimension — that is the CROPS dimension:
First, a provably bug-free Ethereum. About six months ago, "all network security researchers would have thought this was an absurd and impossible goal. And now, thanks to AI-assisted formal verification, it is on the verge of becoming a reality."
Second, high availability of chain consensus. Vitalik emphasized that Ethereum will continue to be the only chain that possesses both the traditional BFT security attributes (high fault tolerance in asynchronous networks) and Bitcoin's PoW security attributes (resisting 49% attacks in synchronous networks) under streamlined consensus.
Third, minimizing intermediaries. "Frankly, protocols like smart contract wallets and railgun must send transactions through intermediaries to go on-chain, which is embarrassing and has always been a weak point." He admitted, "Just achieving 50% does not make Ethereum impressive in the CROPS dimension. So we must pursue 100%."
This "irrational" technical insistence is, in fact, a response to veteran journalist Laura Shin's criticism: Ethereum has not ignored token economics, but is trying to achieve the highest capital premium by establishing extreme "certainty."
4: How to Bridge the Gap of "Interest Alignment"?
Looking back over the past decade, Ethereum has experienced the bursting of the ICO bubble, the DeFi winter, rampant hacking, and multiple bear market impacts, but ultimately completed its self-evolution.
Today, Vitalik's reflection on the Foundation has garnered widespread attention, not only because he responded to external criticisms but more importantly, because it sends a signal: the Ethereum Foundation is gradually transitioning from a past technology-oriented organization to a mature institution that balances organizational governance, ecological coordination, and long-term strategy.
For an ecosystem managing hundreds of billions of dollars in on-chain economic activity, this transformation may not be any easier than any hard fork upgrade.
Lucas Tcheyan, vice president of research at Galaxy, expressed firm support for ETH, stating, "The market is repeating the same mistakes with ETH, just as it did with SOL in 2022/2023. The executive changes at EF are concerning. But Ethereum's roadmap looks more coherent than at any time since the merge."
However, after the Ethereum Foundation further reduces its scope of responsibilities, regarding the viewpoint of many industry professionals that the Ethereum ecosystem needs to create an "organization that aligns with Ethereum's economic interests and is accountable for them," Vitalik and the Ethereum Foundation did not respond to this issue, and the market has not yet seen a viable solution.
This gap of "interest alignment" may be the key to ETH reversing its decline.
You may also like

SpaceX vs Tesla vs xAI: Which Elon Musk Trade Has the Biggest Upside in 2026?

OpenAI Reveals It Has Confidentially Submitted an S-1 to the SEC, Keeping the Door Open for a Future IPO
On June 9, according to an OpenAI announcement, the company recently confidentially submitted a draft S-1 registration statement to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), beginning the preliminary compliance process for a potential initial public offering. OpenAI said it chose to disclose this proactively because it expected the news might leak; however, the company has not yet set a specific listing timeline, and related arrangements may still take some time.

Latest research from 13 top universities including Cornell University: The current state, challenges, and misconceptions of the fusion of Crypto and AI

Deconstructing Anthropic: The Best AI Company, Possibly Also a Type of Organizational Invention

Apollo and Blackstone Reportedly Back $35 Billion Anthropic Chip Financing as Deal Details Remain Unclear
On June 9, according to currently available news alerts, Apollo and Blackstone Group participated in a $35 billion financing for an Anthropic “chip project.” Based on the original wording of the report, the funding has already been raised, but public information remains limited. The financing structure, use of proceeds, project entity, and whether Apollo and Blackstone participated through equity, debt, or project financing have not yet been disclosed.

Humanity Protocol Security Incident Escalates: More Than $31 Million Stolen From Related Addresses as Attacker Continues Selling H for ETH
On June 9, according to monitoring by Onchain Lens, more than $31 million has been stolen from addresses linked to Humanity Protocol, and the attack is still ongoing, with the hacker continuously swapping H tokens for ETH. Project founder Terence Kwok later confirmed the security incident on X, saying the issue involved a private key leak.

Bloomberg: As Bitcoin Weakens, Stablecoins and RWA Continue to Drive Expansion in Crypto Businesses
In June, Bloomberg reported that despite Bitcoin falling below $60,000 last week, wiping out about $235 billion in market value within seven days, and dropping close to 50% from last year’s peak, some core businesses in the crypto industry are still expanding, mainly in stablecoins, real-world asset tokenization (RWA), payments, and infrastructure. The report also noted that overall altcoin activity has contracted significantly: altcoin market capitalization has fallen from a peak of about $431 billion in November 2021 to around $170 billion, and among the tens of millions of tokens issued in recent years, fewer than 1,700 still maintain meaningful trading activity.

Galaxy Deep Research Report: How Hyperliquid's HIP-4 Upgrade Changes the Landscape of Prediction Markets?

Binance Research: RWA Market Expected to Expand Nearly 6x from Early 2025, with Public Equities and Onchain Payments Heating Up Together
In June, Binance Research said in its monthly market report that the real-world asset (RWA) market is expected to grow by about 589% from the beginning of 2025. Bond- and money market fund-related RWA expanded by about $6.5 billion, up 83% year over year, while publicly traded equity RWAs grew by about 422%. The report also noted that monthly crypto debit card transaction volume exceeded $747 million in May, up 48.6% year to date.

Japan to Assess a Framework for Yen Stablecoins and Crypto ETFs as Asia’s Compliant Payments Narrative Heats Up
Recently, according to the original report, Japan is considering the launch of yen stablecoins and cryptocurrency ETFs. Public information remains limited at this stage, and there is still no complete policy text, regulatory draft, or clear implementation timeline, so this is better characterized as a “policy discussion” rather than formal implementation. The original wording also noted that advancing stablecoin regulation in Asia is driving XRP usage and supporting growth in the XRPL ecosystem. However, based on currently available public information, there is not enough evidence to directly establish a clear causal relationship between this round of discussion in Japan and XRP or XRPL.

ZachXBT: Humanity private key leak and abnormal surge in H token should be viewed separately
On June 9, according to related disclosures, on-chain investigator ZachXBT posted an update on Humanity’s roughly $31 million security incident, saying that after further analyzing fund flows, he currently tends to believe the project team was not involved in an “inside job” or a self-staged attack. According to him, the official explanation about the private key leak was broadly accurate, but before the token unlock, the price of H had been artificially pushed higher, and the hacker later took advantage of that market environment; therefore, the private key leak and the earlier abnormal price pumping should be regarded as two separate and independent events. This reframing has shifted the market’s understanding of the nature of the incident. Earlier discussion around Humanity had focused on whether the team directly participated in the attack or used the security incident to cover up internal operations. ZachXBT’s latest remarks shift the focus from “whether it was self-theft” to “whether there were pre-unlock market structure issues.” He also questioned whether the team may have.

Morning Report | OpenAI has submitted an S-1 registration statement draft to the U.S. SEC; Morpho completes $175 million financing

Morning Report | BitMine increased its holdings by 126,971 ETH last week; trader Eugene announced his exit from the crypto market

Wang Chuan: How can one not feel anxious after the neighbor Old Wang made thirty times profit by investing in storage stocks? (Seven) - A quarter-century cycle

Cryptocurrency CEXs are flocking to sell US stocks, and traditional brokerages are facing an "uninvited guest."

$75 billion in foreign capital has fled, and South Korean retail investors have absorbed it all using leverage

Japan’s Three Megabanks Plan Joint Stablecoin Issuance in Fiscal 2026
MUFG, SMBC, and Mizuho reportedly plan to jointly issue fiat-pegged stablecoins in fiscal 2026, signaling Japan’s growing push into bank-led digital payment infrastructure.

Humanity Discloses H Token Dual-Chain Attack Details, With Losses on Ethereum and BSC Exceeding $36 Million
Humanity said the H token attack across Ethereum and BSC caused more than $36 million in losses after leaked ProxyAdmin keys enabled malicious contract upgrades and token minting.
SpaceX vs Tesla vs xAI: Which Elon Musk Trade Has the Biggest Upside in 2026?
OpenAI Reveals It Has Confidentially Submitted an S-1 to the SEC, Keeping the Door Open for a Future IPO
On June 9, according to an OpenAI announcement, the company recently confidentially submitted a draft S-1 registration statement to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), beginning the preliminary compliance process for a potential initial public offering. OpenAI said it chose to disclose this proactively because it expected the news might leak; however, the company has not yet set a specific listing timeline, and related arrangements may still take some time.
Latest research from 13 top universities including Cornell University: The current state, challenges, and misconceptions of the fusion of Crypto and AI
Deconstructing Anthropic: The Best AI Company, Possibly Also a Type of Organizational Invention
Apollo and Blackstone Reportedly Back $35 Billion Anthropic Chip Financing as Deal Details Remain Unclear
On June 9, according to currently available news alerts, Apollo and Blackstone Group participated in a $35 billion financing for an Anthropic “chip project.” Based on the original wording of the report, the funding has already been raised, but public information remains limited. The financing structure, use of proceeds, project entity, and whether Apollo and Blackstone participated through equity, debt, or project financing have not yet been disclosed.
Humanity Protocol Security Incident Escalates: More Than $31 Million Stolen From Related Addresses as Attacker Continues Selling H for ETH
On June 9, according to monitoring by Onchain Lens, more than $31 million has been stolen from addresses linked to Humanity Protocol, and the attack is still ongoing, with the hacker continuously swapping H tokens for ETH. Project founder Terence Kwok later confirmed the security incident on X, saying the issue involved a private key leak.
